Sigrid Kaag, Senior Humanitarian and Reconstruction Coordinator for Gaza, briefs the Security Council meeting on the situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question. Credit: UN Photo
By Dawn Clancy
UNITED NATIONS, Jan 31 2025 (IPS)
Before the three-phased ceasefire deal—proposed by President Joe Biden and dragged over the finish line by the then-incoming Donald Trump administration—silenced the bombs and drones over Gaza and allowed for humanitarian aid to flow into the strip, there was United Nations Security Council Resolution 2720.
Adopted on December 22, 2023, and tabled by the United Arab Emirates, the resolution was created to streamline and accelerate the delivery and distribution of much-needed humanitarian aid to civilians in Gaza. However, critics of the resolution say that a lack of political will and cooperation from the Israeli government and COGAT, the aid coordination arm of Israel’s military—identified by UN bodies and aid organizations on the ground in Gaza as the primary obstruction to aid delivery and distribution—paralyzed the implementation of the resolution’s mandate, unnecessarily prolonging the suffering of Palestinian civilians in the battered and bloodied enclave.
COGAT did not respond to a request for comment.
The resolution also tasked Secretary-General António Guterres to appoint a senior humanitarian and reconstruction coordinator to expedite the mandate and to “establish a UN mechanism for accelerating the provision of humanitarian relief.” For that role, he chose Sigrid Kaag of the Netherlands. She officially started the job on January 8, 2024.
“There are thousands of trucks [with humanitarian aid] trying and failing” to enter Gaza, said Lana Nusseibeh, the UAE’s ambassador to the UN, in her remarks to the Council before the vote in December 2023. “Unless we take drastic action, there will be famine in Gaza.” The situation for Palestinians, she added, is “desperate” and “unbearable.”
In the name of self-defense and security, Israeli Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN, Jonathan Miller, told Council members after resolution 2720 was adopted that Israel “will not change” its approach to the delivery and distribution of aid. In stark contrast to Nusseibeh’s warning of a looming famine in the strip, Miller said, “Hundreds of truckloads of aid enter Gaza every day… the only roadblock for aid entry is the UN’s ability to accept them.”
But Kaag chipped away at Miller’s claim in her first public briefing to the Security Council on April 24, 2024—her first official briefing was a closed session with Security Council members on January 30, 2024—which followed an Israeli airstrike on a World Central Kitchen (WCK) aid convoy in Gaza that killed seven aid workers on April 1.
Notably, before the WCK strike, leadership at the highest levels of the UN recognized the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza. Secretary-General Guterres described the humanitarian situation as “appalling.” And Martin Griffiths, the former UN relief chief, told the Security Council that “providing humanitarian assistance across Gaza is almost impossible.”
Jeremy Konyndyk, the president of Refugees International, in a televised interview, called out Israel for “actively blocking humanitarian groups” from getting into northern and southern Gaza. “What we need to see is the opening of border crossings,” said Konyndyk. “We need to see Israel doing much more to facilitate humanitarian action.”
Meanwhile, the “tragic” and unintentional WCK military strike—as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described it in a video statement—drew heaps of condemnation and criticism from the international community, prompting Netanyahu, after a call with Biden, to make commitments to improve Israel’s approach to humanitarian aid in Gaza, which Kaag noted in her remarks on April 24. Some of these steps included an increase in the volume of aid crossing into Gaza, the temporary opening of the Erez crossing and the opening of Ashdod port for humanitarian goods.
“There’s still a lot of work to be done,” Kaag told reporters after the council meeting. She added that her mandate “requires the full cooperation of the Israeli authorities.”
However, three months after the WCK military strike, on July 29, 2024, while briefing reporters at UN headquarters in New York from Amman, Jordan, Kaag, who had just returned from a trip to Gaza, described the situation as “absolutely catastrophic” and the level of destruction as “almost incomprehensible.” When Kaag returned to New York to brief the Council on September 16, her assessment grew darker.
“Effective humanitarian operations require the right quality, quantity and a broad range of goods to meet the daily needs of civilians in Gaza. That goal is not being met.” She added that the breakdown of law and order and looting of supplies “are additional significant impediments to the UN operations in Gaza. “The operating conditions for humanitarian workers include denials, delays, a lack of safety and security and poor logistical infrastructure. This continues to hamper relief operations,” she said.
Contrary to Kaag’s briefing, Danny Danon, Israeli Ambassador to the UN, in his remarks to the council, described Israel’s humanitarian efforts as “unparalleled” for a country that was forced to go to war.
“We have gone above and beyond our obligations, aiming to improve the well-being of a civilian population embedded within the enemy,” he said. Less than a month later, on October 6, 2024, the Israeli military laid siege to north Gaza, complicating Resolution 2720’s mandate by prohibiting aid deliveries, including food and other essential supplies and trapping upwards of 65,000 Palestinians.
“We have been collectively killing ourselves to establish systems, negotiate, to get dual-use items in, to assist children that are deaf, to get their hearing aids… we’ve established the systems, the teams, the mechanism, the database, we’ve organized the suppliers,” Kaag told reporters in New York on December 10, 2024. “But there’s no substitute for political will. You can’t “ask humanitarians to do more.”
On January 17, 2025, the UN’s press office announced the temporary appointment of Kaag as special coordinator for the Middle East peace process. According to the statement, her new role “will be concurrent” with her present mandate as Gaza’s senior humanitarian and reconstruction coordinator.
Notably, as Kaag worked to implement her mandate to increase and streamline aid into the Gaza Strip, the International Court of Justice (ICJ)—the judicial body of the United Nations—ordered Israel on January 26, 2024, to take steps to prevent genocide in Gaza, including taking all measures within its power to provide adequate access to food, water, fuel, shelter and medical supplies to civilians in Gaza. The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) issued reports of imminent famine in Gaza. Human Rights Watch (HRW) issued a report that detailed how Israeli authorities have “deliberately obstructed Palestinians’ access to the adequate amount of water required for survival.”
Amnesty International published a report on December 5, 2024, concluding that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza by “failing to facilitate meaningful access within Gaza so others, particularly humanitarian organizations, could deliver essential services and life-saving supplies.” And on November 21, 2024, the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and his former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for crimes against humanity and the “war crime of starvation as a method of warfare.”
Additionally, a recent ProPublica investigation revealed that two humanitarian agencies within the US government had concluded last spring that “Israel had deliberately blocked deliveries of food and medicine into Gaza.” The investigation claims that former US Secretary of State Antony Blinken rejected the agency’s findings.
Despite multiple attempts by IPS to interview a variety of humanitarian aid organizations on the implementation of resolution 2720 and its impact on the ground in Gaza—including whether Kaag has effectively executed her ongoing mandate and whether Israel played a primarily obstructive role in the process—some, due to the issue’s sensitivity, declined to speak on the record.
A spokesperson for Islamic Relief did, however, provide IPS with an email statement.
“UN resolution 2720 did not deliver on its mandate to get more humanitarian aid to people in Gaza. It should have led to a massive surge in aid, but instead the amount of aid getting into Gaza decreased even further. Israel has continued to use starvation and denial of aid as a weapon of war, violating international law and UN resolutions with complete impunity.”
A series of humanitarian access snapshot reports published by a group of international humanitarian organizations operating in Gaza also provides insight into the challenges aid workers face despite what Security Council Resolution 2020 has tried to accomplish. These include, according to available snapshots, denials and delays in the delivery of food, medical and building supplies, forced displacement of humanitarian staff and multiple incidents of the Israeli military targeting areas close to aid distribution sites.
After 15 months of war, President Biden, alongside the Trump administration, announced a three-phased ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas, the armed group that attacked Israel on October 7, 2023. The deal’s first phase, which began on January 19, called for a surge in humanitarian aid to Gaza.
The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) has reported that through “interactions with the Israeli authorities and the guarantors for the ceasefire deal,” 915 aid trucks crossed into the Gaza Strip on Monday, January 20, and 897 entered on Tuesday. OCHA estimates that a daily average of 76 trucks carrying humanitarian aid entered Gaza in December 2024. Currently, the flow of aid into Gaza and other critical supplies continues as the ceasefire appears to be holding. It updates humanitarian aid daily.
Still, the uptick in trucks entering Gaza, notably more than the 600 a day stipulated in the ceasefire agreement, has some wondering why aid has been so severely obstructed for the last 15 months.
“You can make the argument that it was more difficult to deliver supplies during Israel’s military campaign than it is during a ceasefire,” said Mouin Rabbani, a nonresident fellow at the Center for Conflict and Humanitarian Studies. However, he added that the sudden surge in aid “shows that there was a decision, a policy to starve the Gaza Strip.”
IPS UN Bureau Report
Follow @IPSNewsUNBureau
L'ambassadeur extraordinaire et plénipotentiaire du Niger près le Bénin, Kakadé BACHIOU est déjà à Cotonou. Il a présenté les copies figurées de ses lettres de créances au ministre des Affaires étrangères ce jeudi 30 janvier 2025.
Vers la normalisation des relations entre le Bénin et le Niger. Le nouvel ambassadeur du Niger, Kakadé BACHIOU, a présenté, jeudi dernier à Cotonou, les copies figurées de ses lettres de créances au ministre des Affaires étrangères, Olushegun Adjadi BAKARI.
La nomination du diplomate nigérien a été approuvée par les autorités béninoises le mercredi 16 octobre 2024.
La Société de Gestion des Déchets et de la Salubrité (SGDS SA) s'ouvre aux populations pour leur permettre de découvrir ses missions et actions essentielles liées au maintien de l'assainissement et de la salubrité dans les villes.
Les Journées portes ouvertes de la SGDS SA se déroulent du jeudi 30 janvier au samedi 1er février 2025. Organisées par composantes opérationnelles (Salubrité publique, gestion des déchets solides, gestion des déchets liquides, hygiène-qualité et sécurité) et composantes supports, les équipes de la SGDS sont installées sous des stands à l'esplanade de l'Amazone. Elles font découvrir les activités de nettoyage et d'assainissement menées dans les villes.
A quelques pas des stands, sont disposés les matériels et quelques engins de travail des agents de la SGDS.
« C'est une occasion donnée à toutes les populations de Cotonou et environs pour voir comment nous fonctionnons au quotidien, apprendre davantage sur les activités que nous menons et également poser des questions », a indiqué Murielle Nounawon cheffe de la Cellule de communication de la SGDS SA.
L'opportunité est également donnée, précise-t-elle, aux populations de s'informer sur le paiement de la redevance d'enlèvement des déchets, les factures en cours de distribution et le mode de paiement. Ceci sous le stand dédié à la sensibilisation et à l'information. « C'est ce stand qui reçoit toutes les personnes qui souhaitent en savoir un peu plus sur le programme d'éducation à l'écocitoyenneté, (...) ou encore nos mesures de sécurité pour protéger nos agents (...) Nous sommes-là de 9h à 19h ».
Quelques actions de la SGDS
Présent sur le stand Salubrité, Jadix Saïnou, superviseur au sein de la société, explique que deux volets majeurs définissent le travail des équipes de la SGDS : le nettoyage des espaces publics et le curage des ouvrages d'assainissement.
Le nettoyage des rues est effectué selon un planning rigoureux. Chaque semaine, les agents interviennent trois fois par semaine, principalement la nuit. Dès 22h, le dimanche, puis le mardi, mercredi et vendredi, les équipes de nettoyage parcourent les rues pavées et bitumées pour ramasser les déchets, le sable et autres détritus. Ils veillent également à maintenir les points de regroupement de déchets en bon état, et à nettoyer les centres de transfert. En journée, une équipe dédiée s'assure de l'entretien des rues, en ramassant les déchets laissés sur place, en enlevant les herbes qui poussent au bord des rues et en nettoyant les espaces publics.
Le second volet important des activités de la SGDS concerne le curage des ouvrages d'assainissement. Trois fois par an, les équipes interviennent sur les collecteurs primaires et secondaires, les bassins pour assurer un entretien complet du réseau. Ces interventions régulières permettent de prévenir les risques d'inondations en maintenant l'efficacité du système d'assainissement.
A ces journées portes ouvertes de la SGDS, le vendredi 31 janvier est consacré à la visite de sites. Il s'agit notamment d'une descente à la station de traitement des boues de vidange à Adjagbo (Abomey-Calavi) ; au point de regroupement d'Agla et au Centre de transfert des déchets à Gbegamey (Cotonou).
Un panel de discussions se déroulera dans la journée du samedi 1er février.
A l'instar de la centaine de visiteurs de la matinée du jeudi 30 janvier, les populations sont attendues aux journées portes ouvertes de la SGDS.
M. M.